Tony Comes is an Ohio Firefighter. His wife Wendy and their two children moved in 2002 into a new home. The next day Tony discovered that five houses down the road lives his worst nightmare - Father Gray who sexually tormented and raped him while being his theology teacher at the Catholic school he attended as a child. As a result of the renewed encounter the trauma and rage that justice was never done surface. Tony decides to expose his story and join a collective law-suit against Father Gray. He discovers that the clerical institution he always regarded as an emotional and moral source of strength and comfort knew of the pedophile priests actions and hid the fact, thus, exposing many children to the same abuse he went  hrough. The film centers on the psychological process Tony has to undergo when confronting the demons of his past from his present position at life.